Happy Challah-ween
Every Wednesday, I teach the 5th through 7th graders in the kitchen. This year, we are making food from different Jewish communities around the world and learning about those communities along the way. So far, we have eaten food from Mexico, Guatemala, and Cuba.
Yesterday, I decided that we would make a food eaten by EVERY Jewish community around the world – challah. The word “challah” actually appears in the Torah. In Numbers 15:20, our ancestors were commanded to bring a “challah,” or loaf, as a gift to God once they entered the Promised Land. Eventually, that word came to mean the delicious loaf of bread with which Jews welcome Shabbat each Friday evening all around the world.
Well, this coming Shabbat is an interesting one on the American Jewish calendar, as it coincides with Halloween. So, my students and I made chocolate chip challah. Some of my budding chefs even added chocolate sprinkles!
As I explained to them, over the years, many Jewish leaders have tried to convince Jewish kids to reject Halloween. I prefer to see our kids bring their Jewish-ness to their celebration of Halloween. This is one more way to do it. We don’t have to give up Halloween to celebrate Shabbat, or vice versa. We can find ways to celebrate both parts of our identity – our Jewish-ness and our American-ness.
As I’ve written in the past, people like to focus on Halloween’s pagan origins. However, the Halloween celebrated by Americans today bears little or no resemblance to the harvest festival celebrated by the ancient Celts and Gaels. It has become a largely secular holiday with two major customs: dressing up in costumes and trick-or-treating. It seems to me that we can infuse these customs with Jewish values.
For example, when choosing costumes with our children, we can take the opportunity to talk about modesty. In particular, some of the costumes available for girls are incredibly inappropriate. Similarly, when deciding what to give out on Halloween and assessing the night’s “haul,” we have an opportunity to discuss kashrut – what we may eat and what is not permissible.
But there is another layer to this. We can “Juda-ize” Halloween and make it better. Instead of focusing on getting as much candy as possible, we can give our kids the opportunity to hand out candy themselves and experience the pleasure of sharing with others. Or, when our kids come home with enough candy to last until 2033, we can send some to the troops or donate it to a food pantry serving children who don’t live in safe neighborhoods.
In today’s world, I don’t think it is reasonable or necessary to ignore Halloween because of our Judaism. However, I would suggest that we should not ignore our Judaism in order to celebrate Halloween. We can take a holiday that is part of American culture and find ways to make it reflect our Jewish values.
So, as my students and I said yesterday when we tasted the results of our labor – Happy Challah-ween!





Comments